'What makes you think that if you're introvert, you'd know it? Being an introvert isn't some kind of special condition, or lack of extraversion.
Energy source is actually a huge simplification. As Benty said, it's the direction of the libido (libido by Jung is our psyche's energy). An extravert is focused on external data, looking at...
Because non of the two points you made makes sense. Care to back them up? Sent from my X5 using Tapatalk
Enneagram isn't by choice in the first place. And while ISFP 8 isn't the most common combination, it's definitely possible. Sent from my X5 using Tapatalk
Show him the description of LSI (ISTj), socionics equivalent of ISTP.
I agree with most of them, but why ESFP for beast?
I'm not going to go into too much depth about the difference between Keirsey and Jungian cognitive functions here, but for example, he wrote (PUMII), that Jung confused introversion with intuition....
Do they have to be Keirsey sensors, or does cognitive functions work? If so, Alexander the Great, Napoleon and Caesar. To be fair, I don't know enough by far about any of those, but how they managed...
What in her seems to indicate Ni and Se?
Know what? That I'm not attracted to them? That they can deal with me?
I don't know what Stand users are, but I guess it's not too relevant to the point. For the record, I have several close friends that can deal with me, and I'm not really attracted by other SJs,...
Care to explain why?
Well first of all, we don't see much of her cognition. She is intelligence in a person, and that's all we see from her. This makes it hard, if not impossible, to make an educated guess on her type. ...
Jester I'll just mention you instead of quoting all of the posts, as there are a few that I'd like to comment on. First of all, knowing that Luke is her brother and that Tarkin is on the ship, is...
Yea, and not just her... The force in general.
Jester Why do you think Leia has high intuition?
What about Melisandre?
SpaceStation Carol A couple of questions: There is a professional right next to you. You always see that you can't perform the way they do. Your feelings, thoughts and actions? When you have to...
What about Ramsay as an ISFJ? I know, it sounds strange, but it does make sense. The whole reason for what he did with Theon is because of the idea he had about his former friend. The general...
Lmiris, I don't have a magic recipe for you, because there is none. And honestly, it might be better to ask other ENFPs (or types that values but has low Te), because for us (and ENTJs), Te is...
The ones I've read is Gifts differing, Psychological types (Jung) and Please understand me II. IMO, Psychological types is the best book there is to understand the basics behind MBTI, as it's the...
But it's not related to type. Which is what your argument was based on. Tywin saying that because Robb lacks experience isn't Si. It's common sense.
Thinking that someone with no experience in warfare would be a bad commander isn't related to type.
It's not like Si has monopoly on using experience for something. ENTJs does this as well. He's referencing that people in general get better by experience.
If someone would come to you and say that there are dinosaurs in another country, would you believe them? Tywin isn't saying that they never existed, (I didn't mean Tywin when I said that people...
Yes, I do agree that it was a great plan. And it did work. But the point is that his own commanders were against it, and that Tywin being Ni or Si wouldn't matter to that working. Because it seemed,...
His mistakes with Robb, Daenerys, his kids, etc, could just as well be Ni. I'm arguing that we have a hard time seeing anything beyond Te in him, because of unhealthy he is. His focus is purely on...
I haven't read A World of Ice and Fire, still looking forward to doing that at some point. But I still have an impression of their types. Rhaenys seems like a sure Fi dom, not sure which. I'm...
Why ESFP over ISFP for Daenerys?
Those without an introverted function.
Correct, Te differs when it's dominant and when it's a tool. But I don't agree that our tools are more apparent. I don't see any reason why the base would be hard to see, or any good source stating...
Mantra why would mostly the auxiliary function show?
Either way, subjective or personal logic is the definition of Ti. Refine your theories, yes. But that's just it. Theories. Disconnected from reality. It's not uncommon for INTPs to reject facts in...
I could really see any ST type, more so ESTJ and ISTP, because of dominant thinking. He's all facts and reality. Possibilities aren't interesting, fantasies aren't interesting, it's all about what's...
Not sure how controversial it is, but Stannis Baratheon as ISTP. Ceasar and Napoleon as probable ESFPs. killvmaim. I agree on Davos, maybe Brianne as well.
While it might be an interesting article, don't take it as MBTI. They say themselves that they're not working with MBTI. MBTI is built by Jung and works with functions, while 16personalities...
I see your point, but it's not technically correct. In psychological types, Myers talks about how the J in introverts is based on their auxiliary function, and that INFPs are dominant introverted...
INFj in socionics is Fi Ne, which correlates to INFP in MBTI. What makes you think ESTJ - INFJ seems to be a good match though? The ones I know I'm not particularly close to, so I can't provide...
1. The one is a fictional dream that comes from too much Disney movies. 2. Intuitives wouldn't be better at it even if it was the case. Actually, no. Most marriages ends in divorces. Not...
Why wouldn't we take much notice of them?
For the record, I don't think that the statistics are really that accurate. From my experience, SJs aren't quite that common, and NFs are a lot more common than they are supposed to be.
ISTJ, ISTP and ESTJ. I can't really see INTJ at all.
I'm not sure he fits the definition of superhero, but I'd probably prefer Iron Man. When it comes to superpower(s), intelligence, knowledge, wisdom. Not really doing nothing, but times when...
It'd be very interesting if someone would do Stannis. For all three types he's commonly typed as. Not sure I can, but I'd be really interested in discussing it if someone did.
Depends on what kind of trip it is. My guess is that I'd have it in the back of my head for weeks before leaving, putting away things that I need, decide what I'll bring, etc. The packing itself...
Type isn't fully translatable. And ISTj in socionics is Ti-Se, while ISTp is Si-Te. So if we would translate, it'd be ENFP and ISTJ that are duals.
I'll go with Dany, that'll probably cause some debate. So the most common typing I've seen for her is INFJ, while I'm pretty sure she's xSFP, most likely ISFP. The main differences being...
ColdWindsRising I'd jump on that train faster than Cersei to wildfire!
StarCraft seems great for ESTJs. I haven't tried it, but if I'd play games, that'd be it.
Right, this sounds very ESTJ. On the other hand, the values of Slytherin is a lot more accurate for an ESTJ. We do not prioritize work over results. I don't know where you got that from. ...'
